As my wife and I have followed the Wall Street bailout drama, the problem of collective action has cropped up again and again in our conversation. What can the individual do when faced with this monumental transfer of resources from the public to the private, when the representatives of the people seem to pay only lip service to the will and demands of their constituents? I don't think people, or 'main street', want to bail Wall Street out, to subsidise and socialise capitalism. This system of private profits and public losses is highly political, far more than it is economic, because government now blatantly responds to needs and demands of special interests and private business and feeds the voters the tired old platitudes about saving the hard-working American from worse fate. My impression is that government hardly ever carries out any policies aimed at directly helping the common man in the United States, yet every single action or fat spend is somehow always to the benefit of the the 'American people'.
The voter can put pressure on his or her representative by calling and writing in, and then follow up at election time with a vote against the politician who has betrayed the democratic trust. Politicians count on the fact that the voter's ideology or common views on a range of issues will win the day. And for unpopular decisions, if democratic and republican senators and house representatives put up a uniform front, what choice is there come next elections? Everybody is guilty. The message is that the decision to give one man unprecedented powers to spend hundreds of billions of government money to buy any debt that financial institutions don't want to carry may be unpopular but since they all agreed to do it, it must be right and the general public just doesn't understand the imminent threat. And then there is really nothing to choose from on this issue when it comes to exercise your vote.
But people can decide to vote on an issue and vote anti-incumbent. Take a stand, on a principle, to vote out the person who supported the bail-out plan - whoever the opposition may be. Just don't cast your vote for a person who you think betrayed their duty as a democratic representative of the people. Against this threat, politicians must pay heed when people write and demand a different course of action. But one person writing doesn't carry much weight. Thousands of voices do make a difference, but usually only if there is a clear threat come election day. The power is in the numbers and in the very direct threat of anti-incumbent voting.
But if people don't have information and they don't organize, the threat of a collective action against politicians evaporates. It is easier for a corporation or a group of companies to organize and lobby the government than it is for the ordinary citizen. Let's look at a simplified example of the sugar manufacture industry. It lobbies the government to raise duties on imported sugar, thus keeping prices higher. The consumer won't do anything because a) the change in price would be small and hardly worth fighting over, and b) to do something about it, you first have information (IE. understand what is going on) and you have to get other people to organize with you to make demands that duties be lifted so price competition can take place. This is classic collective action problem and very hard to overcome.
When the bail-out drama started, we wanted to know how other people felt. By scouring the Internet, we found forums where people 'gathered' to air their anger and grievances. The Internet can be used to share information, to provide links to other sites, and encourage others to write or call their congressman. Before the Internet, this would have taken massive grass-roots organisation, going from house to house, printing leaflets and so forth. The Internet has emerged as a political tool and can address the issues in point b) above: information asymmetry and popular organisation. The actions open to voters remain the same, IE. to pressure the politicians and to vote against them. But this time we can organise to do so more effectively and make the threat of our vote real.
Saturday, 27 September 2008
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
2 comments:
An interesting read, but juxtaposed with the previous entry about stealing corn, I had to laugh! I'm just sayin' ...
I can see why my fantasy about stealing corn might disqualify me from pointing a finger at a corrupt political system...
Post a Comment